 
                     
        | Time | League | Home Team | Score | Away Team | 
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-09-18 
                                    2 : 3
                                 | England FA Vase | Sheffield FC | 2 : 3 
                                    2 : 3
                                 | Loughborough University | 
| 2024-09-14 
                                    5 : 0
                                 | England FA Cup | Rushall Olympic | 5 : 0 
                                    5 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2024-09-07 
                                    0 : 1
                                 | England FA Vase | Sheffield FC | 0 : 1 
                                    0 : 1
                                 | Loughborough University | 
| 2024-08-31 
                                    5 : 0
                                 | England FA Cup | Sheffield FC | 5 : 0 
                                    5 : 0
                                 | Pontefract Collieries | 
| 2024-07-10 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | International Club Friendly | Frickley Athletic | 2 : 1 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2023-09-23 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | England FA Vase | Hanley Town | 2 : 1 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2023-09-09 
                                    1 : 1
                                 | England FA Vase | Sheffield FC | 1 : 1 
                                    1 : 1
                                 | Spalding United | 
| 2023-09-02 
                                    4 : 1
                                 | England FA Cup | Worksop Town | 4 : 1 
                                    4 : 1
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2023-07-29 
                                    4 : 1
                                 | International Club Friendly | Sheffield FC | 4 : 1 
                                    4 : 1
                                 | Matlock Town | 
| 2023-07-15 
                                    1 : 0
                                 | International Club Friendly | Sheffield FC | 1 : 0 
                                    1 : 0
                                 | Newport County | 
| 2023-07-08 
                                    0 : 2
                                 | International Club Friendly | Glossop North End | 0 : 2 
                                    0 : 2
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2022-09-24 
                                    1 : 1
                                 | England FA Vase | Sheffield FC | 1 : 1 
                                    1 : 1
                                 | Ossett United | 
| 2022-09-15 
                                    0 : 0
                                 | England FA Vase | City of Liverpool FC | 0 : 0 
                                    0 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2021-10-09 
                                    3 : 3
                                 | England FA Vase | Bridlington Town | 3 : 3 
                                    3 : 3
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2021-08-07 
                                    0 : 1
                                 | International Club Friendly | Sheffield FC | 0 : 1 
                                    0 : 1
                                 | Coleshill Town | 
| 2021-07-31 
                                    1 : 3
                                 | International Club Friendly | Sheffield FC | 1 : 3 
                                    1 : 3
                                 | Matlock Town | 
| 2021-07-24 
                                    3 : 0
                                 | International Club Friendly | Shepshed Dynamo | 3 : 0 
                                    3 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2021-07-17 
                                    1 : 1
                                 | International Club Friendly | N/A | 1 : 1 
                                    1 : 1
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2020-10-17 
                                    2 : 3
                                 | England FA Vase | Sheffield FC | 2 : 3 
                                    2 : 3
                                 | Runcorn Linnets | 
| 2020-09-23 
                                    2 : 0
                                 | England FA Cup | Coalville | 2 : 0 
                                    2 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2020-09-02 
                                    0 : 0
                                 | International Club Friendly | Matlock Town | 0 : 0 
                                    0 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2020-08-26 
                                    0 : 0
                                 | International Club Friendly | Matlock Town | 0 : 0 
                                    0 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2019-09-28 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | England FA Vase | Clitheroe | 2 : 1 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2019-09-07 
                                    3 : 1
                                 | England FA Cup | Rushall Olympic | 3 : 1 
                                    3 : 1
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2019-07-25 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | International Club Friendly | Sheffield FC | 2 : 1 
                                    2 : 1
                                 | Chesterfield | 
| 2019-06-26 
                                    7 : 0
                                 | International Club Friendly | Chertanovo Moscow | 7 : 0 
                                    7 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2019-06-22 
                                    5 : 0
                                 | International Club Friendly | Torpedo Moscow | 5 : 0 
                                    5 : 0
                                 | Sheffield FC | 
| 2018-07-18 
                                    0 : 3
                                 | International Club Friendly | Sheffield FC | 0 : 3 
                                    0 : 3
                                 | Rotherham United | 
| 2018-07-07 
                                    1 : 5
                                 | International Club Friendly | Sheffield FC | 1 : 5 
                                    1 : 5
                                 | Chesterfield | 
| 2017-08-03 
                                    3 : 2
                                 | International Club Friendly | Staveley MW | 3 : 2 
                                    3 : 2
                                 | Sheffield FC |